Remove Ghooks from Medics

[Carmine]

Yeah, I do know it pretty much nerfs the medical job + the regiments that are actually on the hills but there usually is a regiment with a medic on from either WP, GC or GM. Statements regarding ghooks progression is very true with it becoming mechanically optimised as I remember learning the ghook like 4 years ago and it was an entirely different thing. In the end this suggestion as a whole seems useless and wasn't needed but its just odd, even when I talked with some of the players they also found it very odd for them to just get ghooks as medics.

For me it just doesn't fit in, I'm trying not to be biased and be a person to gatekeep the ghook but if I see something odd and I know I'm not the only one seeing this odd thing then I'll suggest it just so in the end, long term it either has a good safety net to stay around or simply found odd as well by others and simply removed.

I know it was very controversial and some people are now out to get me cause I did a suggestion that just directly nerfs people, to see how it would go. If it gets Denied I'll simply leave it in the past and won't touch on it and its simple as that.

not trying to gatekeep the ghook while actively trying to get it removed from the "not ghook regiments"

 

[Tom]

not trying to gatekeep the ghook while actively trying to get it removed from the "not ghook regiments"

Gatekeeping the ghook, while its accessible by MANY people is crazy. GC, GM, RC, ARC, NSO, Generals and picked medics currently have the ghook. It isn't an item to gatekeep but it should be given in circumstances where it makes sense and as I said many times this exception of 501st and 212th doesn't fit imo I do understand that theres just positives for them having it but like theres no pattern to it, just random.

This whole discussion is as if regiments could add ghooks into their specs which atm I don't think would get passed at all. Im sure K-Company would be able to benefit from them and help others by simply being able to build fortifications in high up areas, Im sure Covert would benefit with the ghook as some places are out of reach from their targets, you see in an ideal world everyone would want to enjoy the ghooks except WP as all it does is bring positives. Obviously it would be ridiculous for them to have it, and yeah I do know that a Medics purpose is different to those who could get a ghook for killing EE's or building fortifications to assist in killing EE's. But would just make sense for it to be more of a spec equipment rather than being equipment only used by 2 regiments.

As I've said to Kixxie for as odd it may sound it would sound better for me if Medical Command pushed the ghook into being given to medics as a whole as it would make sense and wouldn't allow for exceptions instead of it being as it currently is. Or even having a different requirement to it like it being MO+ equipment but in the end, and yeah Im gonna repeat myself, it doesn't make sense for 212th and 501st to just be exceptions and that's all.

 

[Kixxie]

Gatekeeping the ghook, while its accessible by MANY people is crazy. GC, GM, RC, ARC, NSO, Generals and picked medics currently have the ghook. It isn't an item to gatekeep but it should be given in circumstances where it makes sense and as I said many times this exception of 501st and 212th doesn't fit imo I do understand that theres just positives for them having it but like theres no pattern to it, just random.

This whole discussion is as if regiments could add ghooks into their specs which atm I don't think would get passed at all. Im sure K-Company would be able to benefit from them and help others by simply being able to build fortifications in high up areas, Im sure Covert would benefit with the ghook as some places are out of reach from their targets, you see in an ideal world everyone would want to enjoy the ghooks except WP as all it does is bring positives. Obviously it would be ridiculous for them to have it, and yeah I do know that a Medics purpose is different to those who could get a ghook for killing EE's or building fortifications to assist in killing EE's. But would just make sense for it to be more of a spec equipment rather than being equipment only used by 2 regiments.

As I've said to Kixxie for as odd it may sound it would sound better for me if Medical Command pushed the ghook into being given to medics as a whole as it would make sense and wouldn't allow for exceptions instead of it being as it currently is. Or even having a different requirement to it like it being MO+ equipment but in the end, and yeah Im gonna repeat myself, it doesn't make sense for 212th and 501st to just be exceptions and that's all.

My last reply i really promise! Just to give you answer why im not pushing it for being for All medics... Simply put they already have a lot of equipment (327th) and for CG even if they are going FL they stick as group and they have good thing for there spec (armour packs) i will also give simple answer that im not that type of person who just keeps trying to get new / change equipment this will sound crazy but im doing what makes me Happy and in this case create new RP for people to enjoy CRAZY i know but this is simple answer Also for ghook being MO+ would just be already a lot of equipment just MO+ and thats not what i wish

 

[JamesB.]

 

[Eli-]

There's zero reason to remove ghooks from medics, removing the ability for medics to be mobile all over the battlefield when their numbers are thin would be a massive hindrance to the server.

 

[Magma]

remove med kits from medics and give it to arc, I want to combat heal myself

 

[tomery]

remove med kits from medics and give it to arc, I want to combat heal myself

If you want medkit you can’t have ghooks

 

[Jensen]

Lets keep on removing things that no one has ever complained about please.

 

[Turtles]

On behalf of the MVG Administrative Team this suggestion has been Denied, this being done due to we feel this would be detrimental to medics and reaching certain areas for healing and other such places.

// Locked and moved to denied​